How to spot a fake autograph
Most bad autographs are not skilled forgeries. They are printed signatures, machine signatures and signatures by assistants, sold by people who did not check or did not care. Learn the five kinds of non-genuine signature, then look hard at the ink, the paper and the seller.
The five things that are not a genuine autograph
| Type | What it is | How it gives itself away |
|---|---|---|
| Forgery | A signature written by someone else with intent to deceive | Slow, careful, drawn lines; wrong proportions; wrong pen or paper for the date |
| Secretarial | Signed by an assistant, relative or club official on the person's behalf | Fluent and confident, but consistently different from signatures obtained in person |
| Autopen | Signed by a machine that guides a real pen along a stored pattern | Even line weight, dots at the start and end of strokes, identical to other examples |
| Stamp | A rubber or metal stamp of the signature | Flat ink, feathered or blotchy edges, no pen pressure, no variation in stroke |
| Preprint | A signature printed as part of the photograph or card | No ink sitting on the surface; the signature is under the gloss and made of print dots |
Secretarial, autopen, stamped and preprinted signatures were mostly not made to cheat anyone. Film studios, football clubs, politicians and astronauts used them to cope with huge amounts of fan mail. The deception comes later, when they are sold as hand signed.
What to look for in the ink
Use a magnifier of about ten times, a good light and, if you can, the item itself and not a photograph of it.
- Speed. People sign their own name quickly. Genuine strokes taper at the start and finish and flow without hesitation. A forger copying a model writes slowly, so lines can look shaky, evenly heavy and blunt at the ends.
- Pen lifts and patching. Stops in odd places, strokes that have been gone over, and joins that do not quite meet are signs of drawing, not writing.
- Pressure. A ballpoint leaves a groove you can see in raking light and sometimes feel on the back. A printed or stamped signature leaves none.
- Ink on top. Tilt a glossy photograph under a lamp. Real marker ink sits on the surface and reflects differently from the picture. A preprint shines evenly, signature and all.
- Too perfect a match. Nobody signs exactly the same way twice. If your signature can be laid over another example and it matches stroke for stroke, it is an autopen or a print. Genuine examples share habits, not outlines.
- Autopen tells. The machine moves at a steady speed, so the line is the same width throughout, with a small dot or blob where the pen comes down and lifts off, and sometimes a slight wobble on curves.
What to look for in the paper and the item
A signature has to be possible. Check that the pen, the paper and the object all existed when the person could have signed them.
- The pen. Ballpoints were not in everyday use until after the Second World War, and felt-tip markers followed in the 1960s. A marker signature from someone who died in the 1950s is a problem.
- The paper. Paper made since the middle of the twentieth century often contains optical brighteners that glow blue-white under a UV torch. Older paper usually looks dull. It is a rough test, but a brightly glowing "1930s" album page deserves suspicion.
- The photograph. A modern inkjet or laser print of a 1950s film star, with a signature in fresh marker, was not signed in the 1950s. Look at the back for the paper type and any modern branding.
- The object. Shirts, records, books and programmes can all be dated. A signature on a reissue, a later edition or a shirt design that came out after the signer retired, or died, has some explaining to do.
- Ageing that matches. Old ink browns and fades with the paper. Foxing spots that sit on top of the ink in one place and under it in another, or a crisp black signature on a tired, worn page, are worth a second look.
What to look for in the seller
The listing often tells you more than the signature does.
- The price is far below the going rate. Forgers want a quick sale.
- The same item is always available. Multiple copies of a rare signature, or a stock that never runs out, are not how genuine material turns up.
- Vague or shifting provenance. "From a private collection" with no further detail, or a story that changes when you ask.
- A certificate from nobody. Self-issued certificates with no name, address or guarantee. See autograph authentication for what a meaningful one contains.
- Careful wording. "Signed photo print", "reprint", "facsimile signed" and "bears the signature of" are all ways of saying the signature is printed.
- No returns for authenticity. A seller who believes in an item will refund it if it is shown to be wrong.
Signatures that are faked most
Fakes follow demand. The most forged names are the ones everybody wants and few can afford: the biggest names in pop and rock, legendary footballers and boxers, astronauts, film stars who died young and the stars of the largest film franchises. Bands and squads are a special risk, because some members signed for the others. It is well documented that members of the Beatles' own circle signed many items on the group's behalf in the 1960s.
For names like these, assume nothing and expect to pay for a recognised opinion or buy from a specialist with a lifetime guarantee.