Skip to main content

Toy collecting: a guide to vintage and modern toys

Toy collecting covers anything made to be played with, from pre-war tinplate and diecast to last year's building sets. The rules are the same across all of it: condition and completeness decide value, the original box often matters as much as the toy, and you learn far more by handling real examples than by reading asking prices online.

What people collect

Most collectors start with the toys they had, or wanted, as children. That is why demand moves in waves: prices rise while the generation that grew up with a toy is buying it back, and can soften when it stops. Today much of the energy is in toys of the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s.

The main fields, each with its own guide on this site, are:

  • Diecast cars: Matchbox, Corgi, Hot Wheels and the other makers, the scales they used, and why a colour variation can matter more than the model itself.
  • Dinky Toys: the Meccano range made from 1934 to 1979, how to date a model, and how to recognise metal fatigue, repaints and reproduction boxes.
  • LEGO: sealed against built sets, retired lines, minifigures, and how to check a second-hand set is complete.
  • Vintage Star Wars figures: the Kenner and Palitoy figures of 1977 to 1985, carded and loose, and the reproduction accessories that catch beginners out.
  • Teddy bears: Steiff, Merrythought and the British makers, how to date a bear from its materials, and when restoration helps or harms.
  • Model railways: gauges and scales, Hornby O gauge and Dublo, Tri-ang and the modern makers, and how to test a second-hand locomotive.
  • Action figures: Action Man, the cartoon lines of the 1980s and modern collector figures, with advice on completeness and packaging.
  • Retro video games: cartridge and disc eras, boxed and complete games, regional versions, reproductions and looking after old hardware.

Dolls, tinplate, toy soldiers, board games and model kits follow the same principles.

Why boxes matter so much

Toys were bought to be played with and boxes were made to be thrown away. Most were. A toy that survives is uncommon, a toy that survives unplayed with is scarce, and one that still has a clean, complete original box is scarcer again. Collectors pay for that scarcity, so a boxed example can sell for several times the price of the same toy loose, and for some models the box is worth more than its contents.

Check a box as carefully as the toy:

  • Is it the right box? It should match the model, the colour and the period. Makers changed box designs every few years.
  • Is it complete? Look for all the end flaps, the inner packing, the instructions and any leaflets or accessories.
  • Is it original? Reproduction boxes are sold openly for display, which is fine, but they are sometimes passed off as original. New card is usually too white, too clean and too crisp at the folds, and the printing can look slightly soft.
  • Has it been repaired? Tape, replaced flaps and touched-in colour all reduce value and should be mentioned by the seller.
Tip: if you still buy new toys with half an eye on the future, flatten nothing and throw nothing away. Keep the box, the inner tray, the instructions and the spare parts together.

Condition and the language sellers use

There is no single official grading scale for toys. Dealers and auctioneers use descriptive terms, usually giving one grade for the toy and another for the box.

TermWhat it normally means
MintAs it left the factory, with no marks or wear. Used far too freely.
Near mintAlmost perfect, with only the slightest marks from storage or handling.
ExcellentLight wear, such as a few small paint chips or minor rubbing.
GoodObviously played with but complete and presentable.
Fair or poorHeavy wear, damage or missing parts. Mainly of use for spares or restoration.

You will also meet abbreviations such as MIB (mint in box), MOC (mint on card), MISB (mint in sealed box) and CIB (complete in box). Treat all of them as a seller's opinion and judge from clear photographs or, better, from the toy in your hand. For how toy grading compares with other hobbies, see condition and grading.

Originality, restoration and reproductions

Collectors want toys as they were made. A repainted diecast car, a figure with a replacement weapon or a bear with new pads is worth less than an untouched example in the same visible condition, and often much less. Restoration is not wrong, and a well restored toy can be a pleasure to own, but it must be described and priced as restored.

Reproduction parts are made for nearly every popular toy: tyres, decals, missiles, weapons, boxes and instruction sheets. They are useful for completing a display piece. The problem comes when they are not declared. The general checks are in spotting fakes and reproductions, and each guide in this section covers the reproductions particular to its field.

Where to buy

Toy fairs and swapmeets are the best place to start, because you can handle hundreds of items, compare prices between tables and ask questions. Specialist toy auctions offer the widest choice of better pieces, and general auctions and house clearances still turn up childhood collections. Online marketplaces have the largest range but also the most over-graded and undeclared items.

Before you pay, look at what the same toy in the same condition has actually sold for, not what sellers are asking. If you buy at auction, remember the buyer's premium on top of the hammer price. Our auction cost calculator shows the real total.

Storage and display

Light, damp and heat do most of the damage. Sunlight fades boxes and paint and yellows white and clear plastic. Damp rusts axles and tinplate, lifts decals and breeds mould on card and fabric. Lofts and garages swing between hot and cold, which is hard on glue, rubber and old plastics.

  • Keep toys in a lived-in room, away from windows and radiators.
  • Use a closed cabinet for display to keep dust off, and keep it out of direct sun.
  • Remove batteries from anything you are storing. Leaking batteries ruin toys.
  • Do not stack boxes so that the lower ones crush, and do not wrap toys tightly in plastic that can stick to paint.

The wider principles are in storing and displaying a collection.

Selling toys

Do not clean, repaint or repair anything before you sell, and keep every box and loose part with its toy. Common playworn toys are often best sold as a group. Scarce and boxed pieces deserve a specialist dealer or a toy auction. If you have been left a collection, read what to do with an inherited collection first.

Next steps