Skip to main content

What to do with an inherited collection

If you have been left a collection you know nothing about, the best first move is to do nothing that cannot be undone. Do not clean it, split it, tidy it or accept an offer until you know roughly what you have.

What not to do first

Most of the money lost on inherited collections is lost in the first fortnight, by people trying to be helpful.

  • Do not clean anything. Polished coins, washed stamps, repainted toys and re-glued china are worth less, often far less, than the same items left alone.
  • Do not throw away boxes, envelopes or paperwork. Original boxes can be worth as much as the toy inside. Receipts, letters and certificates are evidence of where an item came from.
  • Do not rearrange it. The order a collector kept things in tells a specialist a great deal.
  • Do not break it up among the family yet. A complete set is usually worth more than its parts, and you cannot share something fairly until you know what it is worth.
  • Do not take the first offer. Anyone who offers cash on the spot for the lot is not doing you a favour.

Make it safe where it is

If the collection is in a loft, garage, shed or an empty house, move it somewhere dry, cool and secure. Keep it off the floor and away from radiators and sunlight. Our guide to storing and displaying a collection covers the basics. Tell the home insurer that the items are there, because ordinary contents cover often has limits for single items and for collections. See insuring a collection.

Look for the collector's own records

Serious collectors usually leave a trail. Search the desk, the bookshelf and the computer for:

  • a catalogue, notebook, card index or spreadsheet listing the collection
  • receipts and invoices from dealers and auction houses
  • an insurance schedule or a past written valuation
  • society membership cards, journals and correspondence with other collectors

A purchase invoice tells you what was paid and when, which is the best single clue to which items the collector thought important. A specialist society the collector belonged to is also somewhere to ask for help.

Work out what kind of collection it is

There is a real difference between a collection and an accumulation. An accumulation is a quantity of material gathered without much selection: shoeboxes of loose stamps, jars of old coins, every first day cover bought by subscription for thirty years. It may have cost a lot and still be worth little.

A collection has been chosen. Signs of one include a narrow subject, careful mounting or storage, consistent condition, written notes and evidence of buying from specialist dealers or auctions. These deserve a specialist's eye.

In almost every case, most of the value sits in a small number of items. Your job is to find out which few items matter, so that they are not sold in a job lot with the rest.

If you are dealing with an estate

A collection forms part of the estate of the person who died, so it may need to be valued for probate before anything is sold or shared out. Check the will for any specific wishes, and speak to the executor or the solicitor handling the estate before you remove or sell anything. The government's guidance on valuing an estate is on gov.uk, and the tax position is outlined on our page about tax when you sell collectables. For anything substantial, take professional advice.

Make a simple record

Photograph everything before it moves again, including marks, signatures, labels and damage. Write a rough list as you go. It does not need to be expert. Our guide to cataloguing a collection shows what to note, and the free collection tracker will hold the list.

Getting it valued

Start by looking up what similar items have actually sold for, not what people are asking. Then, for anything that seems to matter, get more than one opinion. Auction houses will often give a free estimate of what a collection might fetch at sale. A written valuation for probate or insurance is a paid service and a different figure. The full method is in how to value a collection.

Tip: Catalogue and price-guide figures are not what you will be offered. Expect offers for a whole collection to be well below them.

Keep, sell or pass on

You do not have to decide quickly, and you do not have to choose one answer for everything.

  • Keep it. If it interests you, carry it on. Many collectors began this way.
  • Keep a few pieces. Choose the items that meant most to the person who built it and sell the rest.
  • Sell it well. Good material generally does best with a specialist auction or dealer in that field. Bulk and common items suit a general sale or a single offer. See how to sell a collection.
  • Give it away. A society, a local museum or a young collector may welcome material that has little market value. Ask first.

Items with legal restrictions

Some inherited items cannot simply be sold. Rules apply in the UK to firearms and other weapons, to ivory and some other wildlife products, and to archaeological finds. If the collection includes anything of that kind, check the current rules on gov.uk before you move or advertise it. Finds from the ground are the business of the Portable Antiquities Scheme.

Next steps