Tax when you sell collectables: a plain-English overview
Most people who sell the odd item from a collection have no tax to pay, but tax can apply in two situations: when you make a large gain on a valuable possession, and when your buying and selling amounts to a business. This page is a general outline to help you ask the right questions. It is not tax advice.
Two different questions
When you sell collectables, the tax system is broadly interested in one of two things.
- A gain on something you owned. If you sell a personal possession for more than it cost you, the profit may fall under Capital Gains Tax.
- Income from trading. If you regularly buy things in order to sell them at a profit, you may be treated as running a business, and the profits may be taxed as income.
Which applies depends on what you are actually doing, not on what you call it.
Capital Gains Tax and personal possessions
The tax rules call movable personal possessions "chattels". Stamps, coins, medals, books, toys, watches, antiques and most other collectables come under that heading.
The general position is that Capital Gains Tax can apply to a gain when you sell a personal possession for more than £6,000. Below that level, a sale of a single possession is normally outside the tax. The official guidance is on gov.uk under Capital Gains Tax on personal possessions, which also explains how the gain is worked out and which possessions are treated differently.
Points worth knowing in outline:
- It is the gain that is taxed, not the sale price. Broadly, the gain is what you received less what the item cost you, with some allowable costs taken into account.
- There is an annual tax-free allowance for capital gains. Its level has changed several times, so check the current figure on gov.uk.
- Some possessions have their own rules. The guidance sets out exceptions and special cases.
- Losses have rules too. If you sell for less than you paid, check the guidance before assuming the loss can be used.
Sets are treated together
You cannot usually avoid the rules by splitting a set into pieces. Items that form a set, such as a matching set of chairs, a set of chessmen or a run of volumes that belong together, can be treated as a single item when they are sold to the same person or to people acting together, even if the sales are spread out. What counts as a set is not always obvious for collectables, so if a valuable group of related items is involved, take advice before selling it in parts.
When collecting becomes trading
Selling your own collection, or parts of it, is not normally a trade. Regular buying and selling for profit can be. There is no single test, but the sort of things that point towards trading include:
- buying items with the intention of selling them on at a profit
- doing so frequently and in an organised way
- selling items soon after you buy them
- repairing or improving items to sell for more
- selling in a way that looks like a business, such as a regular stall or an online shop
If you are trading, you are expected to tell HM Revenue and Customs and to report the profits. There is a small trading allowance for casual income, and online marketplaces now report sellers' details to HMRC in some cases. Both are explained on gov.uk, and the figures involved change, so read the current guidance. If you are near the line, ask an accountant.
Inherited and gifted collections
A collection left to you forms part of the estate of the person who died, and any Inheritance Tax is normally dealt with by the estate, not by you as the person inheriting. If you later sell inherited items, any gain is generally measured from their value at the date of death, not from what the original collector paid. That is one reason a proper probate valuation is worth keeping. Gifts made in someone's lifetime have their own rules. See what to do with an inherited collection for the practical side, and take advice on a substantial estate.
Keep records from the start
Whatever your position, good records make it easy to show. For each significant item, keep:
- the date you bought it, who from and what you paid, with the receipt or invoice
- buyer's premium and other costs of buying
- the cost of any restoration or professional valuation
- the date you sold it, who to, the price and the selling fees
- for inherited items, the probate value
A catalogue of your collection does this job as a side effect. See how to catalogue a collection, or use the free collection tracker to note purchase prices as you go.
When to get professional help
Speak to an accountant or tax adviser if any of these apply:
- you are selling a single item or a set for a large sum
- you are selling a whole collection built up over many years
- you buy and sell regularly and make a profit
- you are an executor, or are dividing a collection among a family
- you are selling abroad or bringing items into the UK to sell
Related guides
- How to sell a collection: the routes to market and their costs.
- How to value a collection: finding a realistic figure.
- Is collecting a good investment?: costs, liquidity and fashion.
- Resale profit calculator: what you actually make after fees and postage.
- Insuring a collection: another reason to keep valuations and receipts.