How to value a collection
A collection is worth what a real buyer has recently paid for the same things in the same condition. Sold prices are evidence. Asking prices, catalogue figures and what you paid are not.
There is more than one kind of value
Before you look anything up, decide which value you need, because the same item can honestly carry three or four different figures.
| Type of value | What it means | When you need it |
|---|---|---|
| Retail or replacement | What it would cost you to buy the same item again from a dealer | Insurance |
| Open market or auction | What it would be expected to fetch if sold fairly on the open market | Probate, dividing an estate, deciding whether to sell |
| Trade | What a dealer would pay you, leaving room for costs and profit | A quick sale to a dealer |
| Net to you | What reaches your bank account after commission, fees and postage | Any sale |
The gaps between these are wide. A dealer's offer is often a fraction of the retail price, and that is not sharp practice: the dealer has rent, stock that sits for years and the risk of being wrong. Knowing which figure you are looking at prevents most disappointment.
Sold prices against asking prices
Anyone can list a common coin for thousands of pounds, and people do. A listing price tells you what one seller hopes for. It is not evidence that anyone has paid it.
Look instead for completed sales:
- Online marketplaces. Most large marketplaces let you filter a search to show sold or completed items. Use that view only, and look at a spread of results rather than the highest one.
- Auction results. Many auction houses publish past results, and auction listing sites keep archives of them. Check whether a quoted price is the hammer price alone or includes the buyer's premium, since the two can differ a good deal.
Compare like with like. The result that matters is one for the same variety, in the same condition, with the same box, papers or signature, sold recently. A mint boxed example tells you very little about a played-with loose one. The guide to condition and grading explains why the difference between grades is often the difference between pounds and hundreds of pounds.
Price guides and catalogues
Printed and online price guides are useful, with limits you should understand:
- Catalogue prices are usually a dealer's retail price for a sound example in a stated grade. In many fields, ordinary material changes hands at well below catalogue.
- Guides date quickly. Fashion moves, and a figure printed some years ago may be too high or too low now.
- Guides are at their best for relative value. They show which dates, varieties and makers are scarce, even when the absolute figures are off.
Use a guide to identify what you have and to spot the better pieces, then confirm the price with sold results.
Auction estimates
An auction estimate is the auctioneer's opinion of the range within which a lot is likely to sell. It is given before the sale, usually without charge, in the hope of winning your consignment. Estimates are often set a little cautiously to encourage bidding, and the hammer price can land well above or below.
Many auction houses hold valuation days or will look at photographs sent by email. This is a sensible first step for anything you suspect is good, and asking two houses costs you nothing.
Paid valuations
A formal written valuation is worth paying for in a few situations: arranging insurance for valuable items, dealing with an estate, dividing property after a separation or a death, or documenting a gift. Before you instruct anyone, ask three things.
- What basis will the valuation use? An insurance valuation gives replacement cost and is normally the highest figure. A probate valuation uses open market value and is normally lower. A document prepared for one purpose should not be used for another.
- How is the fee worked out? A fixed or hourly fee is easier to trust than a percentage of the total, which rewards a high figure.
- What is the valuer's experience in this field? A general valuer may be fine for mixed household contents. A specialist collection needs someone who handles that material regularly.
Be a little wary of a valuation from someone who then offers to buy. It may be perfectly fair, but the two roles pull in opposite directions, so get a second opinion on anything significant. For estates, the official guidance on valuing possessions is on gov.uk, and a solicitor or probate practitioner can tell you what is required.
A method for a whole collection
- List it. You cannot value what you have not counted. See how to catalogue a collection.
- Sort it. In most collections a small number of items carry most of the value. Separate the better pieces from the bulk.
- Research the best pieces one by one using sold prices, and note the source and date of each figure.
- Value the bulk as bulk. Common material sells by the album, box or kilo, not by adding up individual catalogue prices.
- Do not clean, repair or rearrange anything before it has been looked at. You may remove the very thing a buyer would pay for.
- Get expert eyes on anything that looks significant before you insure or sell it.
Related guides
- How to sell a collection: the routes to market and what each costs.
- Insuring a collection: how valuations are used by insurers.
- What to do with an inherited collection.
- Resale profit calculator: turn a selling price into the amount you actually keep.
- Is collecting a good investment?