Book collecting: first editions and how to identify them
To a collector, a first edition means the first printing of the first edition, and for most modern books it has to be in its original dust jacket to be worth much. This page explains how to identify one, and introduces the guides to comics, records and magazines that share this section.
What a first edition is
Strictly, an edition is every copy printed from the same setting of the text, and it may be reprinted many times. Each reprint is a printing, or impression. When collectors and booksellers say "first edition" they almost always mean the first printing of the first edition, sometimes written "first/first" or "1st/1st".
Two other terms catch beginners out. A "first edition thus" is the first appearance of a book in a new form, such as a new illustrated edition, and not the true first. A book club edition is a separate, cheaper printing made for a book club, and is rarely of interest.
Number lines and other ways to tell
Open the book at the copyright page, on the back of the title page. On most books published since the 1970s or 1980s you will find a row of numbers, the number line or printer's key, for example:
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
The lowest number shown is the printing. If the 1 is present, it is normally a first printing. For a second printing the printer removes the 1, so the line ends in 2. The numbers may run upwards, downwards or alternate from the outside in.
The number line is a guide, not a law. Publishers have had their own habits, and a few have used lines without a 1 on their firsts, so check a bibliography or a specialist reference for the publisher concerned. Older books have no number line at all. For those, look for a single date on the copyright page with no mention of later impressions, the same date on the title page, and words such as "First published in" followed by one year. Any line such as "Second impression" or "Reprinted" settles the matter.
Issue points
Issue points are small differences that separate the earliest copies from later ones in the same printing: a misprint corrected during the run, a change of binding cloth, a different price or a review added to the jacket. They matter most for valuable books. The best-known modern example is the 1997 first printing of Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, of which only about 500 hardback copies were printed, identified by a number line running down to 1, the author credited as Joanne Rowling on the copyright page and "1 wand" listed twice on page 53.
You do not need to memorise points. You need to know that they exist and to look them up in a proper bibliography before paying a first edition price.
Dust jackets
For twentieth-century fiction, most of the value is in the dust jacket. Jackets were made to be thrown away, so a first edition in a clean original jacket can be worth many times the price of the same book without one. Check that:
- the jacket belongs to that printing, with the right price and no reviews of later books;
- the price on the front flap has not been cut off, which is called price-clipped;
- the spine has not faded, which is very common on jackets with red or orange spines;
- chips, tears and repairs are described, along with any restoration;
- it is not a modern facsimile jacket, which should be marked as such.
A jacket moved from a later printing onto a first is called a married jacket, and an honest seller will say so.
Signed copies
A book may be simply signed by the author, or inscribed to a named person. Collectors of modern firsts usually prefer a plain signature on the title page. An inscription to someone notable or connected with the author makes an association copy, which can be worth far more. A signed bookplate stuck in afterwards is worth less than a signature on the book itself. Signatures are forged, so apply the checks in autograph authentication.
Condition terms
Booksellers describe the book and the jacket separately, so "VG/VG" means a very good book in a very good jacket.
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Fine (F) | Close to new, with no faults worth mentioning |
| Near Fine (NF) | One or two very minor signs of age or handling |
| Very Good (VG) | A used book with some wear but no serious faults. The usual collectable minimum |
| Good (G) | An average worn copy, complete. In practice, not good |
| Fair or Poor | Heavily worn or damaged. A reading or reference copy |
Words to watch for: foxing (brown spotting), bumped corners, cocked or leaning spines, sunning, owner inscriptions and ex-library, which means stamps, labels and usually a big loss of value.
Where to buy
Charity shops, second-hand bookshops and general auctions are where you learn and occasionally find something. Book fairs put many specialist dealers in one room, and you can handle the books. Members of trade associations such as the ABA and the PBFA trade under codes of practice, which matters for expensive purchases. Online listings vary enormously, so insist on photographs of the copyright page and the jacket flaps, and read buying collectables online safely first.
The guides in this section
This section also covers the other printed and pressed things people collect.
- Collecting children's books and annuals: picture-book firsts, classic series, annuals and Ladybird books, and why good condition is so hard to find.
- Comic collecting: the Beano, the Dandy and 2000 AD, American key issues and first appearances, and where to buy.
- Comic grading and storage: the grades from Poor to Near Mint, when slabbing makes sense, and bags, boards and boxes.
- Vinyl record collecting: first pressings, matrix numbers, labels and sleeves, where to dig and what makes a record valuable.
- Vinyl grading, cleaning and storage: how record grades are used, safe cleaning and the right sleeves.
- Collecting old magazines and newspapers: what is collected, why most historic-headline papers are worth little and how to store newsprint.