Comic collecting: British and American comics
Comic collecting splits into two worlds: British weeklies such as the Beano, the Dandy and 2000 AD, and American comic books led by Marvel and DC. In both, the money follows first issues and first appearances in high grade, and most other comics are cheap enough to collect for fun.
British comics
British comics were weekly papers, printed on cheap newsprint, read by several children and then thrown out or sent for salvage. Survival rates for early issues are low, and that drives values more than age alone.
- The Dandy and the Beano. D. C. Thomson of Dundee launched the Dandy in December 1937 and the Beano in July 1938. The first issues of each came with a free gift, and very few copies survive, fewer still with the gift. They are the most valuable British comics. Pre-war and wartime issues are scarce in any condition.
- Eagle. Launched in 1950 with Dan Dare on the cover, and notable for the quality of its colour printing. Early volumes are collected, often as bound sets.
- 2000 AD. The science fiction weekly began in February 1977, and Judge Dredd first appeared in the second issue, or "prog". Early progs are sought after, mainly with their free gifts. The first one came with a "space spinner".
- Others. War and adventure titles such as Victor, Battle and Action, girls' comics such as Bunty and Misty, nursery titles, football comics and the small-format Commando war libraries all have followings.
Free gifts matter a great deal. A first issue with its gift can be worth several times one without. So do first appearances of famous characters, such as Dennis the Menace in the Beano in 1951. Runs from the 1970s onwards are generally common and inexpensive.
American comics
American comic books are monthly, in colour, and have been collected in an organised way since the 1960s, with price guides, grading standards and a mature market. Collectors divide them into ages. The boundaries are a matter of convention, but roughly:
| Age | Approximate years | Known for |
|---|---|---|
| Golden Age | Late 1930s to early 1950s | The first superheroes: Superman, Batman, Captain America, Wonder Woman |
| Silver Age | Mid 1950s to about 1970 | The revival of superheroes and the birth of the Marvel universe |
| Bronze Age | About 1970 to the mid 1980s | Darker stories and many characters now popular on screen |
| Modern Age | Mid 1980s onwards | Huge print runs in the early 1990s, variant covers and independent publishers |
Key issues and first appearances
A key issue is one in which something important happens, most often the first appearance of a major character. These are the comics with real value. The famous ones include:
- Action Comics 1 (1938), the first appearance of Superman;
- Detective Comics 27 (1939), the first appearance of Batman;
- Amazing Fantasy 15 (1962), the first appearance of Spider-Man;
- The Incredible Hulk 181 (1974), the first full appearance of Wolverine.
High-grade copies of the earliest keys have sold for millions of dollars, which tells you nothing about the comic in your loft. Other things that can make an issue key are the first issue of a long-running title, the origin or death of a character, the first work by a major artist or writer, and a notable cover. Film and television announcements push prices up quickly, and they often fall back afterwards.
The ordinary issues in between are called run fillers or commons, and they can be bought very cheaply, often by the box. Comics from the late 1980s and early 1990s were printed and hoarded in enormous quantities, so "first issue" and "collector's edition" on a cover from that period usually mean very little.
American comics in Britain
Two things are particular to the UK.
- Pence copies. For many years Marvel and DC comics distributed in Britain were printed with a price in pence on the cover in place of cents, or had a British price stamped on. These are original printings from the same run, not reprints. Collectors hold different views on how they should be priced against cents copies, so check sales of pence copies specifically.
- British reprints. Weekly titles such as The Mighty World of Marvel, from 1972, reprinted American stories, mostly in black and white. They are collected in their own right, but a British reprint of a famous story is not the key issue.
Condition
Condition decides price more sharply in comics than in almost any other hobby. The difference between a Very Good copy and a Near Mint one of the same key issue can be tenfold or more. Spine creases, loose staples, missing gifts, cut-out coupons, writing on the cover and brittle pages all count. So does restoration: colour touch-up, tape and trimmed edges must be declared, and they lower the value of a comic against an untouched copy in the same apparent condition.
The grades, professional grading and the right storage materials are covered in comic grading and storage.
Where to buy
- Comic shops. Back-issue boxes are the best education. You can handle the comics and ask questions.
- Comic marts and conventions. Many dealers in one room, with room to haggle on multiple purchases.
- Auctions. Specialist comic auctions handle the valuable British and American material. General auctions sell job lots, where the buyer's premium has to be added to the price. The auction cost calculator works it out.
- Online. The widest choice and the greatest risk of overgrading. Ask for clear photographs of the front, back, spine and centrefold staples.
How to start
Pick something narrow: one character, one title, one artist, the comics you read as a child or a single year of a weekly. Buy readable copies cheaply while you learn to grade, then upgrade the issues that matter.