Skip to main content

Comic grading and storage

Comics are graded on a scale from Poor to Near Mint and beyond, usually with a number from 0.5 to 10. Learn the grades well enough to check a seller's description, pay for professional grading only on valuable issues, and keep everything else bagged, boarded and upright in a box.

The grades from Poor to Near Mint

The same words are used in Britain and America. The numbers come from the ten-point scale used by price guides and grading companies.

GradeNumberWhat to expect
Mint and Gem Mint9.9 to 10.0Effectively perfect. Very rarely awarded
Near Mint (NM)About 9.2 to 9.8Looks new. Only tiny flaws, such as one or two faint spine stress marks
Very Fine (VF)About 7.5 to 9.0An excellent copy with light wear and good gloss
Fine (FN)About 5.5 to 7.0Clearly read, but well kept. Some spine wear and minor creasing
Very Good (VG)About 3.5 to 5.0A well-used copy. Creases, a rolled spine or small tears, but complete
Good (GD)About 1.8 to 3.0Heavily worn. May have tape, writing or a detached staple, but all there
Fair (FR)About 1.0 to 1.5Very worn, perhaps with small pieces missing. Story still readable
Poor (PR)0.5Badly damaged or incomplete

As with books, "Good" is a low grade. Most old comics that have been read by children are Good to Very Good. True Near Mint copies of older comics are rare, which is why they carry such large premiums.

What graders look at

  • The spine. Stress lines, splits, a spine that has rolled round from being folded back, and whether the cover is still attached at both staples.
  • The staples. Rust, and rust staining of the paper around them.
  • The corners and edges. Blunting, creases, chips and tears.
  • The cover surface. Gloss, creases that break the colour, fading, stains and writing. A date or name written by a newsagent is common on British comics.
  • Page quality. White, off-white, cream, tan or brittle. Newsprint darkens and weakens with age and poor storage.
  • Completeness. Cut-out coupons, missing centrefolds, missing pages and missing free gifts.
  • Restoration. Tape, glue, colour touch-up, cleaning and trimming.

Count the pages of anything expensive. A comic with a coupon cut from an inside page can look Very Fine from the outside and be graded far lower.

When slabbing makes sense

Slabbing means sending a comic to a grading company, which examines it, assigns a number, checks for restoration and seals it in a hard plastic case with a label. CGC and CBCS are the companies you will see most. Signed comics can be certified too, if the signing was witnessed under the company's own scheme.

A slab gives a buyer an independent grade and a restoration check, which matters when small differences in grade mean large differences in price. Against that, there is the fee, insured postage, often overseas, a wait and the fact that you can no longer open the comic.

It tends to make sense when:

  • the comic is a key issue worth clearly more than the total cost of grading;
  • it is in high grade, where the number makes the biggest difference;
  • you intend to sell, mainly to buyers who cannot inspect it in person;
  • you want restoration ruled in or out on an expensive purchase.

It rarely makes sense for common issues, low-value modern comics or anything you want to read. A grade is still an opinion. Collectors say "buy the comic, not the label", meaning look at the book inside the case as well as the number.

Bags and boards

Every comic you care about should be in a bag with a backing board.

  • Bags. Polypropylene and polyethylene bags are cheap and fine for ordinary comics, but they are best replaced every several years as they age. Polyester film, often sold under the name Mylar, costs more, is stiffer and clearer, and is the archival choice for valuable comics.
  • Boards. Use boards sold as acid-free, with the coated or glossy side facing the comic. Ordinary cardboard is acidic and will brown the back cover.
  • Sizes. American comics have shrunk over the decades, so supplies are sold in current or modern, silver age and golden age sizes. British weeklies are larger and vary by title, so measure before you order. Magazine-size or specific British sizes are sold for them.
  • Sealing. Fold the flap over or tape it down on the back. If you tape, take care that the comic never touches the tape as it goes in or out. That is how many covers get damaged.
Tip: Keep free gifts with their comic, in the same bag or a second bag stored behind it, with a note. A gift that has been separated from its issue is easy to lose and hard to match up again.

Boxes and shelving

Store bagged comics upright, spine down or on their long edge, in comic boxes made for the job. Fill each box so the comics stand straight without being squeezed, and use a spacer if a box is part full, because leaning causes spine roll. Stacking comics flat in tall piles presses the staples of each one into its neighbours.

Acid-free boxes are best for long-term storage. Keep boxes off the floor, away from outside walls, radiators and sunlight, in a room people live in. Lofts, cellars, garages and sheds are too hot, cold or damp, and damp newsprint goes mouldy and attracts insects and mice.

Handling and repairs

  • Wash and dry your hands. Support the whole comic and open it gently, not flat.
  • Do not use sticky tape on tears. Tape stains and counts as a defect or as amateur restoration.
  • Do not try to press, clean or flatten a valuable comic yourself. Pressing is a specialist service, and done badly it causes damage.
  • Do not write on covers or stick price labels on them. Label the bag.

Related guides