Skip to main content

Card grading explained: is it worth grading your cards?

Card grading means paying an independent company to authenticate a card, score its condition from 1 to 10 and seal it in a tamper-evident case. It is worth doing for a small number of valuable cards in excellent condition. For most cards the fee is more than the value it adds.

What a grading company does

You send the card in, and the company carries out three jobs:

  1. Authentication. It checks that the card is real and has not been trimmed, recoloured, pressed or otherwise altered.
  2. Grading. One or more graders examine the card under magnification and assign a number.
  3. Encapsulation. The card is sealed in a rigid plastic holder, known as a slab, with a label showing the card, the grade and a unique certificate number.

The certificate number can be looked up on the company's website, which lets a buyer confirm that a slab is real. The companies also publish population reports: counts of how many copies of each card they have graded at each level.

PSA, Beckett, CGC and SGC are the long-established American names, and there are grading companies based in the UK and Europe as well. This site does not recommend one over another. Compare sold prices to see which company's slabs buyers of your kind of card prefer.

What graders look at

  • Centring. Whether the borders are even, left to right and top to bottom, on the front and the back.
  • Corners. Sharp and square, or softened, whitened or bent.
  • Edges. Chipping, whitening and roughness from the factory cut.
  • Surface. Scratches, print lines, dents, stains, fingerprints and loss of gloss.

Some companies print a separate sub-grade for each of the four on the label.

The 1 to 10 scale

Wording varies between companies, and some use half points, but the shape of the scale is the same everywhere.

GradeUsual descriptionIn plain terms
10Gem MintEffectively perfect: sharp corners, clean surface, well centred
9MintOne very minor flaw
8Near Mint to MintLooks perfect at arm's length, slight wear or centring fault close up
7Near MintLight wear on corners or surface
5 to 6ExcellentVisible corner rounding and surface wear, no major damage
3 to 4Very GoodRounded corners, light creasing or scuffing
1 to 2Good to PoorHeavy wear, creases, stains or damage

A card that is real but cannot receive a number, because it has been trimmed or altered, may be returned labelled as authentic only, or with a note of the problem.

The gap in price between adjacent grades is not even. For modern cards the jump from 9 to 10 can be several times the price, because buyers of new cards want perfection. For old cards, where a 10 may hardly exist, a 5 or 6 can be a desirable grade. A grade is also an opinion, and the same card can come back a point different on another occasion.

Costs

Fees change often, so check the company's current price list. The elements are consistent:

  • The fee per card, set in tiers by how fast you want it back and by the card's declared value. Valuable cards cost more to grade.
  • Postage and insurance both ways. Send tracked and insured for the full value.
  • Import charges, if the company is overseas. Cards returning to the UK from abroad can attract VAT or duty depending on how they are declared and shipped. Some collectors use a UK-based submission service, for a further fee. General rules are on gov.uk.

As a rough guide, the all-in cost per card at the cheapest service level usually runs from the low tens of pounds, and more at faster levels or for high-value cards.

Waiting times

Turnaround depends on the service level you pay for and on how busy the company is. Economy services commonly take from several weeks to several months. When demand surges, waits can be far longer. Do not send a card for grading if you may need to sell it soon.

When grading adds value

Grading tends to pay when all of these are true:

  • The card is worth clearly more than the total cost of grading, even at a middling grade.
  • Its condition is good enough to earn a high number, or it is old and scarce enough that any authenticated grade is wanted.
  • Buyers of that card normally pay more for graded copies. Look at sold prices for raw and graded examples.
  • Authenticity is a real concern, as with early Pokémon cards and famous rookie cards and football stickers.

It rarely pays for bulk modern cards, for played childhood cards with obvious wear, or for anything you simply like and will keep. British cigarette cards and trade cards are mostly bought and sold ungraded, by set, and slabbing is unusual outside the rarest single cards.

Tip: Before paying, do the sum. Take the sold price for the grade you realistically expect, subtract every cost of grading and selling, and compare the result with the raw sold price. The resale profit calculator will do the arithmetic.

Preparing a card and judging it yourself

Examine the card under a bright lamp with a magnifier, tilting it to catch surface scratches. Be strict: most people overestimate their own cards by a grade or two.

Handle the card by its edges and put it in a new soft sleeve. Do not try to improve a card by pressing, trimming or cleaning it. Altered cards are rejected.

Buying graded cards

A slab is reassurance, not a guarantee. Counterfeit slabs and genuine slabs that have been opened and resealed with a different card both exist. Check the certificate number against the company's records and inspect the case for frosting or cracks along the seams.

Related guides