Skip to main content

Coin grading explained: from Poor to Uncirculated

A coin's grade is a description of how much wear it has had since it was struck. In the UK grades are given in words, from Poor at the bottom to Uncirculated at the top, and the gap in price between one grade and the next can be larger than the gap between a common date and a scarce one.

Why grading matters

Catalogues and price guides list a different value for each grade. A Victorian penny in Fine might be worth a pound or two, and the same date in Uncirculated many times that. If you cannot grade, you cannot tell whether a price is fair.

Grading is a judgement, not a measurement. Aim to be consistent and a little strict.

The UK grades

GradeAbbreviationWhat you see
PoorPVery heavily worn. The type can be identified but the date or legend may be partly gone.
FairFrHeavily worn, but the main design, legend and date can be made out.
FineFConsiderable wear on all the raised parts. The design is clear but flat, with little fine detail left.
Very FineVFLight to moderate wear on the high points only. Most detail in hair and design is still there.
Extremely FineEFVery slight wear, visible only on the highest points on close inspection. Much of the original surface remains.
UncirculatedUncNo wear at all. May show bag marks from contact with other coins at the Mint.

Dealers fill the gaps with prefixes. "Good" means better than the grade, and "Near" or "About" means just short of it, so the ladder runs Fine, Good Fine, Near Very Fine, Very Fine and so on. "About Uncirculated" describes a coin with only the faintest rub.

Two further terms describe top-end coins. Brilliant Uncirculated (BU) is an uncirculated coin with full original lustre, or a modern coin struck to that standard for collectors. FDC, from the French fleur de coin, means flawless and is used mainly for proofs.

Proof is not a grade

A proof is a coin made by a special process: polished dies and blanks, struck more than once, to give sharp detail and mirror-like fields. It describes how the coin was made, not its condition. A mishandled proof can be scratched and hairlined, and is then an impaired proof, not an uncirculated coin.

How to grade a coin

  1. Hold the coin by the edge under a single good light, and use a 10x magnifier.
  2. Find the high points of the design, which wear first. On a portrait these are the hair above the ear, the eyebrow and the cheek. On a reverse they might be Britannia's knee and breast, or the lion on a shield.
  3. Look for flat, dull patches on those high points. Any flatness means the coin is not Uncirculated.
  4. Tilt the coin. Original mint lustre moves across the surface like a cartwheel. Wear breaks it up.
  5. Grade each side separately, then go with the lower one.
  6. Note separately anything that is not wear: edge knocks, scratches, corrosion, cleaning.
Tip: Compare your coin with dealer photographs of the same type in each grade. Grading one coin in isolation is hard. Grading it against five reference images is much easier.

The 70-point scale

American collectors, and the international market for expensive coins, use a numerical scale from 1 to 70. It is often called the Sheldon scale, after William Sheldon. The numbers sit under familiar names:

  • Good (G) 4 to 6 and Very Good (VG) 8 to 10.
  • Fine (F) 12 to 15.
  • Very Fine (VF) 20 to 35.
  • Extremely Fine (EF or XF) 40 to 45.
  • About Uncirculated (AU) 50 to 58.
  • Mint State (MS) 60 to 70, with 70 a perfect coin. Proofs use PR or PF with the same numbers.

The names match the British ones but the standards do not line up exactly. Traditional British grading is generally stricter: a coin a UK dealer calls Extremely Fine may be graded About Uncirculated on the American scale, and a British Very Fine is often an American Extremely Fine. Check which system a seller is using.

Slabbing

Third-party grading companies, of which PCGS and NGC are the best known, examine a coin, give it a number on the 70-point scale and seal it in a tamper-evident plastic holder known as a slab. The label records the coin, the grade and a serial number.

The advantages are an independent opinion, some assurance that the coin is genuine, and easier selling to buyers abroad. The drawbacks are the fee, postage and insurance, and the fact that you can no longer handle the coin.

Slabbing makes sense for valuable coins where a point of grade means real money, and for coins that are often faked. It rarely makes sense for coins worth less than the cost of the service. The wider debate is covered in condition and grading across collecting hobbies.

Why you should never clean a coin

Cleaning does not improve a grade. It creates a new problem. Metal polish, abrasive cloths, wire brushes and chemical dips strip the surface and leave fine parallel scratches called hairlines. Collectors recognise the unnatural brightness instantly, and a cleaned coin sells at a heavy discount, sometimes for half or less of an untouched example.

The natural toning that silver and copper develop over decades is part of the coin. Many collectors pay more for attractive, even toning. If a coin has active green corrosion or loose dirt, the right response is careful storage and, for anything valuable, advice from a specialist. See how to store a coin collection.

Related guides