Skip to main content

How to sell coins and coin collections

Sort the collection first, find out roughly what you have, and then match each part to the right buyer: bullion coins to a bullion dealer, good collector coins to a specialist dealer or auction, and low-value material in bulk. Do not clean anything, and get more than one offer.

Before you do anything

  • Do not clean the coins. Cleaning can halve the value of a good coin. Dealers want them exactly as found.
  • Keep everything together. Boxes, certificates, old dealer tickets, envelopes with notes and the collector's own catalogue all help a buyer and can add value.

Sort it into groups

Most collections, and nearly all inherited ones, are a mixture. Sorting shows you where the value is.

  1. Gold. Sovereigns, half sovereigns and other gold coins. These have a firm minimum value from their metal. See gold sovereigns.
  2. Silver. British silver coins dated before 1920 are sterling silver, and those dated 1920 to 1946 are half silver. From 1947 the "silver" coins are cupro-nickel. Even worn examples of the earlier coins have a metal value.
  3. Collector coins in good condition. Anything sharp, old or unusual. Set aside for a closer look.
  4. Royal Mint sets and proofs. Keep them in their cases with certificates.
  5. Modern change. Commemorative 50p and £2 coins. Check them against our guides to rare 50p coins and rare £2 coins.
  6. Worn bronze, foreign holiday change and everything else. Usually sold by weight or as a job lot.

Be realistic about group six. A biscuit tin of worn twentieth-century pennies and foreign coins is typically worth a few pounds, however old the coins look.

Find out roughly what it is worth

You do not need exact figures, only enough to know whether an offer is sensible. Use a current British coin price guide to identify anything with a high listed value, then check what similar coins in similar condition have actually sold for. Catalogue prices are what a dealer might charge for a coin, not what a dealer will pay.

Condition drives everything, so read coin grading explained and grade strictly. The general method is in how to value a collection.

Where to sell

RouteBest forDrawbacks
Coin dealerSpeed and certainty. Mixed collections. Immediate payment.You are paid a trade price, below retail.
Bullion dealerCommon gold and silver coins sold for their metal.No premium for scarce dates, so check those first.
Specialist coin auctionScarce and high-grade coins, where collectors compete.Seller's commission and other charges. Weeks or months to be paid. No guaranteed result.
General auctionHouse-clearance collections of modest value.Fewer specialist bidders. Lots are often grouped.
Online marketplaceIndividual modern coins and sets with a known market.Fees, postage, photography, returns and the occasional dishonest buyer.

The routes are compared in more detail, for all collectables, in how to sell a collection.

How dealers price coins

A dealer has to resell at a profit, pay overheads and sometimes hold a coin for years. The offer reflects that. As a broad picture:

  • Bullion coins are bought close to their metal value, because they can be resold the same day.
  • Popular, saleable collector coins are bought at a moderate discount to the retail price.
  • Common, low-grade material is bought at a small fraction of catalogue value, or declined, because it is slow to sell.

How auctions price coins

An auction house gives each lot an estimate, a range in which it expects the hammer to fall. You can usually agree a reserve, a price below which the lot will not be sold. From the hammer price the house deducts its seller's commission and any agreed charges such as photography or insurance, usually with VAT on those fees.

Buyers pay a premium on top of the hammer price, and they bid with that in mind, so it affects what you receive even though you do not pay it. Ask for the full terms in writing before you consign. Our guide to buying at auction explains the process from the other side.

How to avoid being underpaid

  • Get at least two offers for anything substantial, and tell each dealer you are doing so.
  • Know the gold and silver value before you walk in. Weigh the coins, look up the day's metal price and work out the floor.
  • Look for trade body membership. Dealers who belong to a recognised numismatic trade association sign up to a code of conduct.
  • Be wary of unsolicited buyers, including doorstep callers and travelling "roadshow" buying events. You may get a fair price, but you have no comparison and little time to think.
  • Never post coins on approval to a buyer you have not checked. If you must post, use an insured, tracked service and photograph everything first.
Tip: Make a simple list with photographs before showing the collection to anyone. It lets you compare offers on the same basis and gives you a record if something goes missing.

Inherited collections

If the collection came from an estate, there may be a formal step first. Executors often need a written valuation for probate before anything is sold, and several heirs may need to agree. Ask the solicitor or check gov.uk if you are unsure.

Look for the collector's own records. Serious collectors keep purchase notes and tickets that identify each coin, and sometimes name the dealer they trusted. Our guide to what to do with an inherited collection covers the first steps in detail.

Selling coins can have tax consequences in some circumstances. See tax when you sell collectables for an outline and take professional advice for large sums.

Next steps