Skip to main content

Error coins and mis-strikes: what is real and what is not

A genuine error coin is one that went wrong during manufacture at the mint and escaped into circulation. They exist and some are valuable, but they are rare. The great majority of coins sold online as "rare errors" are worn, damaged or perfectly normal.

How errors happen

A coin is made in three broad stages. Metal is rolled into strip and blanks are punched out of it. The blanks are prepared and, for some coins, given edge lettering. Then each blank is struck between two dies inside a collar that holds it in place and forms the edge.

Something can go wrong at each stage, and collectors group errors accordingly: blank errors, die errors and striking errors. Modern mints inspect their output closely, so the more dramatic the error, the less likely it was to get out.

The types collectors recognise

Blank (planchet) errors

  • Clipped blank. The punch overlapped a previous hole or the edge of the strip, leaving a curved or straight piece missing.
  • Wrong blank. A coin struck on a blank meant for another denomination or another country's coinage. The classic British example is a "silver" 2p, a 2p design struck on a cupro-nickel blank intended for a 10p. The coin will be the wrong weight and often the wrong size for its design.

Die errors

  • Mule. A coin struck from two dies that were never meant to be paired. The best-known modern British example is the undated 20p of 2008. When the reverse designs were changed that year, the date moved from the reverse to the obverse. Some coins were struck with the new reverse and an old obverse, so they carry no date at all. Many thousands entered circulation, and they still sell for a healthy premium.
  • Wrong legend. In 1982 the wording on the 2p changed from NEW PENCE to TWO PENCE. A small number of 1983 coins were struck with the old NEW PENCE reverse. They are known from collector sets of that year and are scarce and valuable.
  • Die cracks and cuds. A cracked die leaves a raised line on the coin. A piece broken from the die edge leaves a raised blob, called a cud. Minor cracks are common and add little.

Striking errors

  • Off-centre strike. The blank was not seated properly, so part of the design is missing and part of the blank is unstruck.
  • Double strike. The coin was struck twice, with the second impression offset from the first.
  • Brockage. A struck coin sticks to a die and impresses its design, mirror-reversed and sunken, into the next blank.
  • Die rotation. One die turns in the press, so the two sides are no longer aligned as they should be. Small rotations are common. Large ones are collected.

Error or post-mint damage

Most "errors" found in change are damage that happened after the coin left the mint. The key question is whether the feature could have been produced by the striking process.

What you seeUsual explanation
Coin is the wrong colourPlating, heat, chemicals or burial. Copper-plated steel coins lose plating and corrode. Science-lesson experiments turn coins silver or gold.
Design looks doubled, flat and shelf-likeMachine doubling, a slight bounce of the die. Very common, not collected.
Missing detail or lettersWear, a grease-filled die, or deliberate removal. Rarely adds value.
Reversed, sunken impression of another coinTwo coins squeezed together in a vice. A real brockage is sharp, and the coin is the correct weight and shape.
Centre of a £2 or £1 missing or swappedPushed out after it left the mint.

Damage moves metal: look for raised ridges beside a gouge, flattened lettering, or a rim that has been hammered. A genuine striking error shows crisp detail in the wrong place, with metal that has flowed under pressure.

Checking a suspected error

  1. Weigh it. Pocket scales reading to a hundredth of a gram are the most useful tool. A wrong-blank error will not match the standard weight. A plated or acid-treated coin gives itself away too.
  2. Measure it for diameter and thickness, and compare with a normal coin of the same type.
  3. Examine it under 10x magnification, comparing it side by side with a normal example.
  4. Search for the specific error in specialist references. Known errors are documented. If nobody has recorded it, be sceptical.
  5. Get an opinion. Take the coin to a dealer at a coin fair or to a numismatic society meeting. For something that looks significant, a third-party grading company can authenticate and attribute it.
Tip: Normal variation is not an error. Coins of the same design differ slightly in strike, colour and alignment, and £2 edge lettering is upside down on about half of all coins. None of this has a market.

Why most "rare error" listings are nothing of the kind

Online marketplaces let anyone list anything at any price. A common coin with a scratch can be titled "RARE ERROR" and priced at £5,000, and the listing costs the seller almost nothing. Newspapers then report the asking price as if it were the value.

The test is simple: look at completed sales, not active listings, and see whether that exact error has sold repeatedly to different buyers. Real errors have a track record at specialist auctions.

What genuine errors are worth

It depends on how dramatic the error is, how many are known and which coin it is on. Minor errors, such as small die cracks or slight clips, sell for a few pounds. Dramatic, visually obvious errors on popular modern coins can sell for hundreds, and the scarce documented ones for more. Authentication matters more as the price rises.

Related guides