Skip to main content

What are cigarette cards worth?

Most cigarette cards are worth less than their owners hope: a common 1930s set in good condition sells for a few pounds, and cards stuck into albums for less. Real value lies in early issues, scarce makers and popular subjects in clean condition, and it is not hard to tell which you have.

Why most sets are inexpensive

Price depends on how many survive against how many people want them. The big makers printed their inter-war sets by the million, families saved them carefully, and the number of collectors is smaller than it was a generation ago. Age alone does not make a card scarce.

So the typical inherited collection, made up of Wills and Player's sets from the 1920s and 1930s, is pleasant but modest.

Sets against odd cards

Cards are worth most as complete sets. Check the back of any card for the series title and the number in the series, usually 25 or 50, then count what you have.

  • Complete sets are what buyers want and what catalogues price.
  • Part sets are worth much less than their share of the full set, because the buyer must find the missing cards.
  • Odd cards from common series sell for pennies each, often by the bundle. Odds from scarce early series are a different matter and can be worth pricing one by one.

A set should also be matched: the same printing, similar condition throughout and all with the same back. Several series were issued by more than one maker or with different brand names on the back, and a mixture is not a true set.

Condition

Condition moves the price more than anything else once you know the set. Collectors look at the corners first, then creases, surface marks, foxing and the back.

ConditionWhat it looks likeEffect on price
Excellent or betterSharp corners, clean face and back, no creasesFull price, and a premium for early cards
Very goodSlight corner rounding, clean, no creasesThe usual collectable grade, somewhat below full price
GoodRounded corners, light marks, perhaps a faint creaseA fraction of full price for common sets
Fair or poorCreased, stained, written on, trimmed or paper stuck to the backLittle or nothing unless the card is rare

Dealers and catalogues do not all use identical terms, so read the definitions each one gives. Our page on condition and grading compares the language used across hobbies.

Stuck-down albums

From the 1930s many sets were printed with gummed backs to be stuck into a penny album sold by the maker. Almost everyone did as they were told. The result is that these albums are extremely common, and because the backs are hidden and the cards cannot be removed without damage, collectors pay very little for them. A stuck-down album typically sells for a pound or two, sometimes less in a bulk lot.

The same sets unstuck, with clean gum on the back, are worth more, though still not much for common titles.

Tip: Do not soak cards out of albums in the hope of raising the value. Soaked cards lose their surface finish and are easy for a buyer to spot.

What makes a set valuable

  • Early issue. Cards from before the First World War were printed in smaller numbers, and fewer survive in clean condition. Sets from the 1890s and 1900s can be worth tens or hundreds of pounds, and the scarcest far more.
  • Scarce makers. Small firms with local sales issued far fewer cards than the national brands. An unfamiliar maker's name is always worth looking up.
  • Subject. Sport leads, especially cricket, football, golf and boxing, because sports collectors compete with card collectors. Film stars, aviation, motoring, railways and military subjects also sell well. Flowers and general knowledge are slower.
  • Unusual formats. Silks, large cards and sets with a short print run often carry a premium, though silks must be clean and unfrayed.

At the very top are legendary rarities such as Taddy's unissued clowns series, where single cards have sold for very large sums.

Catalogue price against selling price

Annual catalogues published by the card trade list a price for almost every British series, as sets and as odd cards. They are the best way to see which sets are common and which are not. Remember what the figures mean: they are retail prices for cards in top condition, bought one set at a time from a dealer who holds stock.

If you sell, expect a good deal less. A dealer buying a general collection has to allow for cards that will sit unsold for years, and may offer a small proportion of catalogue value for common sets, with a better proportion for scarce ones. Auction results and online sold listings show what buyers actually pay. Asking prices on unsold listings tell you nothing.

Checking a collection in an afternoon

  1. Separate loose cards from stuck-down albums.
  2. Sort loose cards by the maker and series title on the back, and count each set.
  3. Put aside anything pre-1914, anything from a maker you do not recognise, all silks and all sporting sets.
  4. Look those up in a catalogue or in sold listings, and note the condition honestly.
  5. Treat the rest as a group lot.

If the better pile looks promising, a specialist card auctioneer or a member of a cartophilic club will usually give an opinion. For a formal figure for probate or insurance, see how to value a collection. Reprint sets are worth only a pound or two, and are normally identified as reprints on the back.

Next steps