Skip to main content

Collecting model railways: Hornby, Bachmann and vintage trains

Model railway collecting splits into two camps: people who collect vintage trains as historic toys, and people who buy models to run on a layout. Both need to understand gauge and scale first, because a train only has value to a buyer whose track it fits.

Gauges and scales

Gauge is the distance between the rails. Scale is the size of the model compared with the real thing. The two are linked but not identical, and British practice differs from the rest of the world in several sizes.

NameTrack gaugeScaleNotes
Gauge 145 mmAbout 1:32Large early toy trains, and garden railways today
O gauge32 mm7 mm to the foot, about 1:43The standard toy train size between the wars
OO gauge16.5 mm4 mm to the foot, about 1:76The main British size since the 1950s
HO gauge16.5 mmAbout 1:87The main size in Europe and America. Same track as OO, smaller models
TT12 mm1:120, or 3 mm to the foot for older British modelsA table-top size, made by Tri-ang from the late 1950s and revived in recent years
N gauge9 mmAbout 1:148 in Britain, 1:160 elsewherePopular where space is short

Within a gauge, systems still differ. Older trains may be clockwork or electric, and electric trains may collect power from a third centre rail or from the two running rails.

Hornby O gauge

Meccano Ltd of Liverpool, Frank Hornby's company, introduced Hornby clockwork trains in 1920. They were made of printed and enamelled tinplate, at first held together with nuts and bolts in the Meccano manner, and the range grew through the 1920s and 1930s to include electric locomotives, a wide choice of wagons and coaches, stations, signals and other accessories.

The most admired pieces date from the 1930s: the larger locomotives modelled on real express engines, and vans and wagons in advertising liveries. Production continued in simpler form after the war and faded out in the 1960s. Rust, repainting and replaced parts are the main faults.

Hornby Dublo

Hornby Dublo, launched in 1938, brought the same quality to OO gauge. The locomotives had heavy diecast bodies and the track had a third centre rail. The system returned after the war and was at its height in the 1950s, when it was the train set many British children wanted.

A two-rail version and plastic-bodied rolling stock arrived at the end of the 1950s, but by then the range was expensive beside its rivals. Lines Bros, owner of Tri-ang, took over Meccano in 1964 and Dublo production ended. Some of the tooling passed to Wrenn, whose own models are now collected in their own right.

Dublo is robust and plentiful, so ordinary three-rail sets are not expensive. The premium is on boxed items in fine condition and scarce later models.

Tri-ang and Tri-ang Hornby

Tri-ang Railways appeared in the early 1950s: plastic-bodied, two-rail, and much cheaper than Dublo. It sold in enormous numbers. After the takeover of Meccano the two ranges were combined under the name Tri-ang Hornby in the mid 1960s, and the range became Hornby Railways in the early 1970s. The Hornby name has continued on OO gauge trains ever since.

Because so much was made, common Tri-ang models are cheap, which makes the range a friendly place to start.

Other makers

  • Bassett-Lowke. A Northampton firm known for high quality O gauge and larger models, aimed more at adults than children.
  • Trix. Made the Trix Twin system from the 1930s, which allowed two trains to be controlled on one track.
  • Bachmann. Its Branchline range has been a main competitor to Hornby in British OO since about 1990.
  • Lima, Mainline and Airfix. Makers of the 1970s and 1980s whose models are plentiful second hand.

Modern models are far more detailed than vintage ones and are bought mainly to run.

Testing a second-hand locomotive

  1. Look before you power up. Check for cracked or swollen castings, missing buffers, couplings, handrails and wheels, and for rust on tinplate. Diecast chassis and wheels from some periods suffer from metal fatigue, which cannot be repaired.
  2. Check it is original. Look for repainting, replacement transfers, renumbering and non-original wheels or motors.
  3. Test on clean track of the right type, in both directions, at low and high speed. A healthy motor runs smoothly without hesitation, grinding or a smell of burning.
  4. Expect to service it. A locomotive that has sat for decades usually needs cleaning and a little oil in the right places. Dried grease is not a fault in itself. A burnt-out or missing motor is.
  5. Wind clockwork gently. Do not force a mechanism that resists, and check that the key fits properly.
Tip: do not plug in an old mains transformer or controller to test a train. Insulation and wiring deteriorate with age. Use a modern controller, or have vintage electrical equipment checked by someone qualified first.

Boxes and values

As with all toys, the box matters. Sets should have their inner packing, track, key or controller, and instructions. Reproduction boxes exist for the popular ranges and should be sold as such.

Most unboxed, played-with post-war OO is inexpensive: wagons and coaches for a few pounds each, ordinary locomotives in the tens. Boxed items in fine condition cost more, and the scarcest pre-war O gauge locomotives and rare Dublo and Wrenn models can reach hundreds or thousands at specialist sales. Check sold prices for the exact model, livery and condition.

Collectors' societies exist for most of these ranges, including the Hornby Railway Collectors' Association and the Train Collectors Society.

Related guides