Collecting badges and pins
Badges are small, cheap, easy to store and made for every club, cause and company you can think of. Most cost a pound or two. The skill is in recognising the handful that are scarce, and that starts with turning the badge over.
The three main types
Enamel badges
A metal badge, usually brass or gilding metal, die-stamped with a design and filled with coloured enamel. Traditional vitreous or "hard" enamel is powdered glass fired in a kiln and polished flat, so the surface is smooth, hard and level with the metal lines. It cannot be dented with a fingernail.
Later and cheaper badges use "soft" or cold enamel, which is a paint or resin. It sits slightly below the metal lines, or is covered with a clear domed coating. Hard enamel generally indicates an older or better-quality badge, though it is still used today.
Button badges
A printed paper disc under a clear cover, wrapped over a metal shell with a pin behind. The type was developed in the United States in the 1890s and spread quickly. Early button badges have a celluloid cover, which yellows and can crack. Later ones use a clear plastic film.
Pin badges
The modern lapel pin: a small die-struck or cast badge with a post on the back held by a butterfly clutch. Most date from the 1980s onwards. Football clubs, charities, tourist attractions and brands issue them constantly.
What people collect
Holiday camp badges
The British holiday camps issued enamel badges to guests. Butlin's badges are the most collected: from the 1930s to the 1960s the company produced a different design for each camp and each year, plus badges for staff, committees and special weeks. That gives collectors a long, checkable list to complete. Common post-war badges are inexpensive, and the early and short-lived issues are much scarcer.
Football and sport
Club enamel badges, supporters' club badges and the pin badges sold at grounds since the 1970s. Older supporters' club badges in hard enamel by known makers are the most wanted.
Political and campaign badges
Election badges, trade union badges, peace campaign badges and those from strikes and protests. They are collected as social history. Badges from the 1984 to 1985 miners' strike are a well-defined field. Suffragette badges and jewellery are rare and valuable, and they are faked, so they need expert opinion and provenance.
Clubs, societies and children's clubs
Children's clubs run by comics, radio programmes, food brands and road safety campaigns issued badges to members, and many adults collect the ones they once wore.
Advertising and brand badges
Companies have given away badges for well over a century, as premiums collected with labels or tokens, as staff badges and as promotions.
The best known British series is the set of enamel "Golly" brooches issued by the jam maker Robertson's from the late 1920s until 2001, obtained by saving tokens from jars. They exist in many designs, including musicians and sportsmen, and they are widely collected and documented, with pre-war examples the scarcest. The figure is a golliwog, which is now widely recognised as an offensive racial caricature, and the company retired it. Some other historic advertising and novelty badges use imagery of the same kind. Collectors and museums generally treat such pieces as evidence of the attitudes of their time. Some auction houses and online marketplaces restrict or decline them, so check a venue's policy before you try to sell.
Makers' marks
Good enamel badges usually carry the maker's name and town on the back, stamped into the metal or on a raised tablet. Birmingham, and its Jewellery Quarter in particular, was the centre of the trade, with London second. Names you will see often include Thomas Fattorini, J. R. Gaunt, H. W. Miller and W. O. Lewis, among many others.
The mark helps in two ways. It confirms that a badge is a proper period product and not a modern copy. Firms changed their name style and address over the years, so the wording can narrow the date. Button badges often have the maker's name printed on the rim or on a paper disc inside the back.
Condition
- Enamel: chips, cracks and missing colour are the main faults. Tilt the badge under a light to find hairline cracks. Repairs done with paint or resin look dull beside real enamel.
- Button badges: rust spots coming through the paper, known as foxing, plus scratches, dents, fading and cracked celluloid.
Copies and restrikes
Popular badges have been reproduced, and some old dies have been reused to make restrikes. Warning signs are soft enamel where the original was hard, a missing or wrong maker's mark, modern fittings, colours that are slightly off, and a seller offering many identical "rare" badges in perfect condition. The general checks are in spotting fakes and reproductions.
Values
The great majority of badges sell for a pound or two, and modern pin badges often for less, especially in bulk. Better hard enamel badges from collected series commonly make several pounds to the tens of pounds. Scarce early issues, rare club and campaign badges and anything with firm provenance can go well beyond that. As always, judge by sold prices and not by what optimistic sellers are asking.
Storage and display
- Keep them dry. Damp rusts steel pins and button badge shells and turns brass green. A sachet of silica gel in the box helps.
- Stop them rubbing. Badges loose in a tin scratch and chip one another. Use trays with compartments, or pin them to a board.
- Do not polish. Metal polish strips thin gilding and leaves residue in the detail. A soft dry cloth is enough.
Related guides
- Football memorabilia: club badges alongside shirts, medals and tickets.
- Medals and militaria: cap badges and service badges.
- Cricket, rugby, golf and Olympic memorabilia: including Olympic pins.
- Breweriana and advertising: other promotional collectables.
- Storing and displaying a collection: damp, light and safe materials.