Collecting fountain pens
Fountain pens are one of the few antiques you can use every day. A good vintage pen from a well-known maker can cost less than a modern one, but only if you know how it fills and what state its nib and ink sac are in.
Vintage or modern
Collectors loosely call a pen vintage if it dates from before the ballpoint took over in the 1950s and 1960s. Vintage pens offer characterful gold nibs and handsome materials at modest prices, with the catch that most need some restoration before they will write.
Modern pens work out of the box and take cartridges. Limited editions are produced in large variety, and most are worth less second-hand than they cost new. Buy modern pens because you like writing with them.
Filling systems
How a pen takes in ink is the first thing to identify. It tells you the pen's rough period and what is likely to need repair.
| System | How it works | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Eyedropper | The barrel itself is filled with ink using a dropper | The earliest type. Simple, with nothing to perish, but can leak at the joint |
| Lever | A lever on the barrel squeezes a rubber sac inside | The most common vintage system. The sac will almost certainly need replacing |
| Button | A button under a cap at the end of the barrel squeezes the sac | Used on many pens of the 1920s and 1930s. Also needs a new sac |
| Plunger and vacuum | A rod or diaphragm creates a vacuum that draws ink in | Holds a lot of ink. Repairs are a specialist job |
| Piston | Turning the end of the barrel moves a piston up and down | Long used by German makers. Seals can dry out but usually recover or can be replaced |
| Squeeze or aerometric | A sac inside a metal sleeve is pressed with the fingers | Common from the late 1940s. Often still working after decades |
| Cartridge and converter | A sealed ink cartridge, or a small refillable piston unit in its place | The modern standard. Check which cartridge shape the pen takes |
Nibs
The nib is the part that matters most. Good vintage pens have gold nibs, usually stamped 14ct or 14K, tipped with a small ball of hard alloy that does the actual writing. Cheaper pens have steel nibs, which can still write very well.
Check these with a loupe before you buy:
- Tipping: both halves of the tip should still have their hard metal ball. A nib worn or broken back to the gold will scratch.
- Alignment: the two tines should meet evenly, with a thin, regular slit between them.
- Cracks: look at the breather hole and along the slit.
The classic makers
- Parker: the Duofold of the 1920s, the striped Vacumatic of the 1930s and the hooded-nib Parker 51, introduced in the 1940s and one of the best-selling quality pens ever made. Many Parkers were made in England for the British market.
- Waterman and Sheaffer: the other great American names, both with long ranges of lever-fill pens and later designs.
- Conway Stewart: the favourite British make, loved for its colourful marbled and patterned plastics.
- Onoto: made by De La Rue, known for plunger-filling pens.
- Mabie Todd: maker of the Swan and Blackbird pens, with well-regarded nibs.
- Montblanc and Pelikan: the leading German makers, known for piston fillers.
Materials and their weaknesses
Early pens are black or mottled hard rubber, also called ebonite or vulcanite. It fades from black to brown or olive with light and water, and fading lowers value. From the 1920s celluloid brought colour and pattern. Some British makers also used casein, a milk-based plastic that swells and cracks if soaked. Later pens are injection-moulded plastics, which are tougher.
The practical rule is simple: do not soak an old pen, and do not use hot water on one. Gold-filled trim wears through to brass on the clip and cap bands. Collectors call it brassing, and it is one of the first things to look for.
Restoration
Almost every sac-filling pen that has sat in a drawer for fifty years has a perished sac. Replacing one is routine and inexpensive, and many collectors learn to do it themselves on cheap pens first. Opening a pen takes gentle dry heat and patience, since old barrels crack if forced.
How to buy a pen that writes
- Decide whether you want a restored pen or a project. "Restored" or "serviced" should mean a new sac or seals and a tested nib. "Untested" usually means it does not work.
- Check the cap lip, the barrel threads and the section for cracks.
- Work the lever, button or piston gently. If it is stiff, stop: forcing it breaks things.
- Examine the nib tip with a loupe.
Buying from a specialist or at a pen show costs more than buying unseen, and you get a pen that works. The Writing Equipment Society is the UK body for collectors, and pen shows are held in several cities each year.
Values
Ordinary lever-fillers and school pens sell for a few pounds unrestored. Good, serviced examples of the classic models by the main makers typically run from the tens of pounds to the low hundreds, depending on colour, size and condition. Large pens, rare colours, early hard rubber in unfaded condition and pens with precious metal overlays fetch more. Check sold prices for the exact model and colour, since both make a large difference.
Related guides
- Antiques and curios: the other small antiques on this site.
- Buying collectables online safely: reading listings and checking sellers.
- Collectors' fairs, clubs and societies: pen shows and societies.
- Storing and displaying a collection: safe materials.