Skip to main content

Collecting pocket watches

Pocket watches are one of the most affordable ways into antique horology. Learn the case styles, tell a fusee from a lever movement, read the hallmarks inside the case, and judge each watch on its movement and condition.

A short history

Portable watches have been made since the sixteenth century, and for some three hundred years the pocket watch was the normal way to carry the time. In the nineteenth century, Swiss workshops and then American factories using machine-made interchangeable parts brought prices down until almost anyone could own one.

Case styles

StyleDescription
Open-faceNo cover over the glass. The winding crown is normally at 12 o'clock.
Hunter (full hunter)A hinged metal lid covers the dial and springs open when the crown is pressed. The crown is normally at 3 o'clock.
Half hunter (demi-hunter)A hunter with a small window in the lid, and hour numerals on the lid, so the time can be read with it shut.
Pair caseAn inner case holding the movement, inside a separate protective outer case. Typical of the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries.

Winding: key and keyless

Early watches are wound and set with a small separate key, through holes in the back or the dial. From the mid nineteenth century keyless winding through the crown gradually took over, and by the early twentieth century it was almost universal.

Movements: verge, fusee and lever

The movement is where most of the interest lies, and where you date and judge a pocket watch.

  • Verge escapement. The oldest type, used from the earliest watches into the nineteenth century. Verge watches are thick, not very accurate and usually have a pierced and engraved bridge over the balance, called the balance cock, which is often beautiful.
  • Fusee. Not an escapement but a device to even out the pull of the mainspring. A fine chain runs from the spring barrel to a cone-shaped pulley, the fusee, so that the force stays steadier as the spring runs down. You can see the chain and cone by looking into the side of the movement. Fusees are found with verge and with lever escapements, and English makers kept using them long after others had stopped.
  • Lever escapement. Developed in England in the eighteenth century and refined in the nineteenth, it became the standard for good watches and is still the basis of mechanical watches now. An "English lever" usually means a nineteenth-century English watch with this escapement, often with a fusee.

Reading the case: hallmarks and other marks

British-made silver and gold cases carry hallmarks struck inside the back: a standard mark showing the metal's purity, the mark of the assay office that tested it, a date letter and the case maker's initials. Read together they tell you where and in which year the case was assayed. Imported cases were required to be hallmarked in Britain from the early twentieth century and carry their own style of import marks. Silver hallmarks explained shows how to read them.

Keep two points in mind:

  • The hallmark dates the case, not the movement. Movements were often recased, so check that the two fit each other properly and that their serial numbers agree where both are numbered.
  • Continental silver cases are usually stamped with a fineness number such as 0.800 or 0.935 instead of British marks.

Many cases are not solid precious metal. Gold-filled and rolled gold cases have a layer of gold over base metal and are often stamped with a number of years for which the maker guaranteed the gold layer against wearing through.

Makers and names

The name on an English watch is very often the retailer, a jeweller in a provincial town who bought the watch finished or had it completed for him. That is normal and not a fault.

American factory watches, from firms such as Waltham, Elgin, Hamilton and Illinois, are well documented. Serial number lists for the main makers have been published, so a movement can usually be dated and its grade identified. The high-grade watches built to the standards the American railroads demanded of their staff are a popular field.

What decides value

Values vary enormously, and any figure without the watch in hand is a guess. In general terms, common silver and plated watches in ordinary or non-working order sell for modest sums, solid gold cases have a floor set by their gold content, and the high prices go to fine or complicated work. The factors are:

  • Movement quality and complications. Chronographs, repeaters and calendar watches, and high-grade movements of any kind.
  • Maker. A recorded, respected maker or a top factory grade.
  • Case metal. Gold over silver over plated or base metal.
  • The dial. Enamel dials crack and chip. Hairlines are common and reduce value, and a perfect dial is a real plus.
  • Originality. Matching case and movement, original hands, no crude repairs.

Check sold prices at auction for comparable watches, not asking prices. See how to value a collection.

Tip: Do not let anyone scrap a gold pocket watch for its metal before the movement has been looked at by someone who knows watches. A good movement can be worth more than the case.

Buying and caring for a pocket watch

Ask to see the movement, and whether the watch winds, sets and runs. Look for rust, missing screws and scratches around the screws that suggest careless repair.

Wind gently and stop when you feel resistance. Do not run an antique watch for long if it has not been cleaned and oiled in living memory. Store watches dry, and remember that none of them are water resistant.

Related guides